Hello, everyone. Over on the Mudcat Forum, there was a discussion about Robert Johnson's records being sped-up. This discussion transitioned into one Blues fan's remembering meeting Mississippi John Hurt and asking him about the magnificent "Frankie", which was recorded in 1928 or 1929, and is considered one of the greatest guitar recordings in probably the history of Western music. The following is the post by the gentleman who met Hurt, and my response. I'd be curious to see what everyone thinks! I hope it's all right to post something that was found on another forum.
"Back to Mississippi John Hurt (this is for you, Hoot):
The song in question was "Frankie's Blues," one of only two MJH selections included in the landmark 6-LP set Anthoogy of American Folk Music.
From page 189, Dave Van Ronk's The Mayor of MacDougal Street:
"Spike Driver's Blues" was one of two songs by John that had been included on the Anthology. The other was this gorgeous piece of fingerpicking called "Frankie's Blues." It was a beautiful arrangement, and when those albums came out in the early 1950s, we all immediately set ourselves to learn that thing. It was incredibly fast, though, and after a week or two I dropped by the wayside. A few persisted, and my friend Barry Kornfeld, for one, disappeared into his chambers and emerged six weeks later, blinking like a mole, and he had it. Note for note, just as clean and fast as on the record.
When I first saw John at the Cafe Yana, there he was playing "Frankie's Blues." However, I noticed that it was a lot slower than on the record. Of course, he was a good deal older, but it also struck me that it sounded better at that tempo. I wanted to ask him about it, but I wanted to be as diplomatic as possible ~ I didn't want to just say, "So, Pops, can't cut it anymore, eh?" Very tentatively, I said, "You know that 'Frankie' thing you played..."
Apparently I was not the first person to have asked, because John intervended and saved me any further embarrassment. He just smiled and said, "Oh, you want to know why it's so much slower than on the record."
I said, "Yeah..."
He said, "Well, you know, that song was so long that they had to speed it up to get it all on one side of a 78."
All I could think of was Barry, sidelined with acute carpel tunnel syndrome."
My response:
"That really sucks! I thought that "Frankie" was one of the most amazing recordings ever, and now I find out that it was sped-up! Oh well! Well, I believe that Michael Bloomfield recorded a version of "Frankie" that sounded just like Hurt's old record, and that guys like Stefan Grossman and Ernie Hawkins are capable of playing the song at the same tempo of the record from 1928 or 1929. Man, that's kind of disappointing! Is there a chance that Hurt said that just so his then-current version of the song wouldn't appear to pale in comparison to the original? It was, after all, forty years after he'd recorded the piece when you saw him."
"Back to Mississippi John Hurt (this is for you, Hoot):
The song in question was "Frankie's Blues," one of only two MJH selections included in the landmark 6-LP set Anthoogy of American Folk Music.
From page 189, Dave Van Ronk's The Mayor of MacDougal Street:
"Spike Driver's Blues" was one of two songs by John that had been included on the Anthology. The other was this gorgeous piece of fingerpicking called "Frankie's Blues." It was a beautiful arrangement, and when those albums came out in the early 1950s, we all immediately set ourselves to learn that thing. It was incredibly fast, though, and after a week or two I dropped by the wayside. A few persisted, and my friend Barry Kornfeld, for one, disappeared into his chambers and emerged six weeks later, blinking like a mole, and he had it. Note for note, just as clean and fast as on the record.
When I first saw John at the Cafe Yana, there he was playing "Frankie's Blues." However, I noticed that it was a lot slower than on the record. Of course, he was a good deal older, but it also struck me that it sounded better at that tempo. I wanted to ask him about it, but I wanted to be as diplomatic as possible ~ I didn't want to just say, "So, Pops, can't cut it anymore, eh?" Very tentatively, I said, "You know that 'Frankie' thing you played..."
Apparently I was not the first person to have asked, because John intervended and saved me any further embarrassment. He just smiled and said, "Oh, you want to know why it's so much slower than on the record."
I said, "Yeah..."
He said, "Well, you know, that song was so long that they had to speed it up to get it all on one side of a 78."
All I could think of was Barry, sidelined with acute carpel tunnel syndrome."
My response:
"That really sucks! I thought that "Frankie" was one of the most amazing recordings ever, and now I find out that it was sped-up! Oh well! Well, I believe that Michael Bloomfield recorded a version of "Frankie" that sounded just like Hurt's old record, and that guys like Stefan Grossman and Ernie Hawkins are capable of playing the song at the same tempo of the record from 1928 or 1929. Man, that's kind of disappointing! Is there a chance that Hurt said that just so his then-current version of the song wouldn't appear to pale in comparison to the original? It was, after all, forty years after he'd recorded the piece when you saw him."