Hi all,
Ed Bell recorded "She Got A Nice Line" as Barefoot Bill at a session in Atlanta in 1930 for which he was joined by his neighbor, Pillie Bolling. Bolling, who was interviewed by Swedish researcher Bengt Olson in 1975, recalled that Bell wrote the song on the way to Atlanta on the back of a train timetable. The song is a chorus blues of the "Tight Like That" family, made considerably more interesting than most songs of that type by being rougher and more "country". To my taste, at least, the less such songs are like conventional Pop music of the era, the more I like them. This song also shows Bell to capable of playing much closer to the Pop Blues mainstream of his time than his solo songs suggest he might have been.
Bolling, who I believe is handling the lead guitar chores, is working out of G position in standard tuning, and is doing a lot of double octave fretting on the sixth and first strings, dragging his hand up and down the neck to get the melody notes he seeks, much as John Hurt did on his solo for "Casey Jones".
Bell and Bolling's singing of the refrain is what I would describe as "beneficially loose" in a way you very rarely hear in present-day players of the music. They often sing slightly different versions of the lyrics and don't sound to be worrying about tight harmonies or spiffy entrances and exits to their vocal phrases. EDITED, TO ADD, ON 12/4: In order to give the best idea of how Bell and Bolling sing the refrains, I have listed Bell's singing of the refrains in the body of the lyrics. Here is how Bolling handled his singing of the refrains.
Bolling joins Bell for the singing of the first half of each of the first two lines of the refrains: "Oh, she got a nice line", but drops out for the second half of those lines and leaves them for Bell to sing alone. [On one verse, Bolling forgets to come in on the first line of the refrain until "nice line".] In the final line of the refrains, Bolling generally waits to come in on the word "got", and then sings the remainder of the line, though, as will be seen, he does differ in how he sings the lines from Bell on several occasions. Here is what Bollling sings for the final lines of his refrains:
REFRAIN 1: Got a nice line, you just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 2: Got a nice line, but your mammy don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 3: Got a nice line, but your mama don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 4: Got a nice line, but your mammy don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 5: Got a nice line, but she just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 6: 'Cause she got a nice line, just, just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 7: Got a nice line, she just don't know her stuff
There is more consistency and sense to the way Bell and Bolling approached this than was apparent when I first listened to the song. Thanks to dingwall for suggestions on how best to communicate the duo's singing of "She's Got A Nice Line".
The girl I love, live on 18th Street
She got a new line for every man she meet
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, your mama don't know your stuff
To let her tell it, she ain't got no man
But she hangs around cabarets raisin' sand
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line but [word omitted] don't know her stuff
SPOKEN: Now, do it! Ah, shucks, now!
One day we was out, we're ridin' along,
I asked her, "How about it?", and she walked back home
REFRAIN: Oh, she's got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she's got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, your mama don't know her stuff
She don't do this, she don't do that
Rub your hand down her back, she act like a cat
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line,, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, but just don't know her stuff
SPOKEN: Ah, do it, boy! Boy, that's the way my gal like it!
She ain't low and squatty, she ain't long and slim
The only way you'll get it, have to grab you a limb
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line but she just don't know her stuff
---t'ain't right, I don't have fun
This girl I love won't give me none
REFRAIN: Oh, I got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, but just don't know her stuff
SPOKEN, BELL: Now, do it--th' last time, boy! I want you to do it good this time. You know how you were doin' it last Saturday night down at that booger rooger?
SPOKEN, BOLLING: Sure!
SPOKEN, BELL: When my and your gal was there, boy, and your gal hollered, "Do it, Mr. Pillie!"
SPOKEN, BOLLING: The whole town just heard.
I want it right now, please tell me, can I get it?
I better not catch nobody else with it
REFRAIN: 'Cause she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, she just don't know her stuff
Edited, 11/19 to pick up correction from banjo chris
Edited, 11/21 to pick up corrections from dingwall
All best,
Johnm
Ed Bell recorded "She Got A Nice Line" as Barefoot Bill at a session in Atlanta in 1930 for which he was joined by his neighbor, Pillie Bolling. Bolling, who was interviewed by Swedish researcher Bengt Olson in 1975, recalled that Bell wrote the song on the way to Atlanta on the back of a train timetable. The song is a chorus blues of the "Tight Like That" family, made considerably more interesting than most songs of that type by being rougher and more "country". To my taste, at least, the less such songs are like conventional Pop music of the era, the more I like them. This song also shows Bell to capable of playing much closer to the Pop Blues mainstream of his time than his solo songs suggest he might have been.
Bolling, who I believe is handling the lead guitar chores, is working out of G position in standard tuning, and is doing a lot of double octave fretting on the sixth and first strings, dragging his hand up and down the neck to get the melody notes he seeks, much as John Hurt did on his solo for "Casey Jones".
Bell and Bolling's singing of the refrain is what I would describe as "beneficially loose" in a way you very rarely hear in present-day players of the music. They often sing slightly different versions of the lyrics and don't sound to be worrying about tight harmonies or spiffy entrances and exits to their vocal phrases. EDITED, TO ADD, ON 12/4: In order to give the best idea of how Bell and Bolling sing the refrains, I have listed Bell's singing of the refrains in the body of the lyrics. Here is how Bolling handled his singing of the refrains.
Bolling joins Bell for the singing of the first half of each of the first two lines of the refrains: "Oh, she got a nice line", but drops out for the second half of those lines and leaves them for Bell to sing alone. [On one verse, Bolling forgets to come in on the first line of the refrain until "nice line".] In the final line of the refrains, Bolling generally waits to come in on the word "got", and then sings the remainder of the line, though, as will be seen, he does differ in how he sings the lines from Bell on several occasions. Here is what Bollling sings for the final lines of his refrains:
REFRAIN 1: Got a nice line, you just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 2: Got a nice line, but your mammy don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 3: Got a nice line, but your mama don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 4: Got a nice line, but your mammy don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 5: Got a nice line, but she just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 6: 'Cause she got a nice line, just, just don't know her stuff
REFRAIN 7: Got a nice line, she just don't know her stuff
There is more consistency and sense to the way Bell and Bolling approached this than was apparent when I first listened to the song. Thanks to dingwall for suggestions on how best to communicate the duo's singing of "She's Got A Nice Line".
The girl I love, live on 18th Street
She got a new line for every man she meet
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, your mama don't know your stuff
To let her tell it, she ain't got no man
But she hangs around cabarets raisin' sand
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line but [word omitted] don't know her stuff
SPOKEN: Now, do it! Ah, shucks, now!
One day we was out, we're ridin' along,
I asked her, "How about it?", and she walked back home
REFRAIN: Oh, she's got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she's got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, your mama don't know her stuff
She don't do this, she don't do that
Rub your hand down her back, she act like a cat
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line,, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, but just don't know her stuff
SPOKEN: Ah, do it, boy! Boy, that's the way my gal like it!
She ain't low and squatty, she ain't long and slim
The only way you'll get it, have to grab you a limb
REFRAIN: Oh, she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line but she just don't know her stuff
---t'ain't right, I don't have fun
This girl I love won't give me none
REFRAIN: Oh, I got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, but just don't know her stuff
SPOKEN, BELL: Now, do it--th' last time, boy! I want you to do it good this time. You know how you were doin' it last Saturday night down at that booger rooger?
SPOKEN, BOLLING: Sure!
SPOKEN, BELL: When my and your gal was there, boy, and your gal hollered, "Do it, Mr. Pillie!"
SPOKEN, BOLLING: The whole town just heard.
I want it right now, please tell me, can I get it?
I better not catch nobody else with it
REFRAIN: 'Cause she got a nice line, she used it rough
Oh, she got a nice line, she can't get enough
She's got a nice line, she just don't know her stuff
Edited, 11/19 to pick up correction from banjo chris
Edited, 11/21 to pick up corrections from dingwall
All best,
Johnm