Musically, yes I agree, for a start McTell starts the rap phase with a Dm position, not a C. The general lyrical idea and title are a thorough cop from McTell though. To be pedantic though it's not St James Infirmary, since that is usually a minor song as well.
« Last Edit: November 08, 2007, 05:03:44 AM by Rivers »
When Ken Burns was putting together his nine-hour (get it?) documentary on Baseball, he said he was amazed that he couldn't find any other songs on the topic that everyone could relate to besides "Take Me Out To the Ball Game." He said all of the others were novelty tunes about topics of the day, such as Les Brown's swing tune, "Joltin' Joe Dimaggio," which was a big hit when Joe was in his 56-game hitting streak. 56 games, still can't believe it. For that reason, the Burns' documentary has something like 50 or 60 different renditions of "Take Me Out" playing in the background. One version, done in a Merle Travis style, still sticks in my mind. Here's your chance to write a classic CB version of the song.
Found this after I posted my last message, the lyrics to Joltin' Joe Dimaggio (1941):
Hello Joe, whatta you know? We need a hit so here I go. Ball one (Yea!) Ball two (Yea!) Strike one (Booo!) Strike two (Kill that umpire!) A case of Wheaties
He started baseball's famous streak That's got us all aglow He's just a man and not a freak, Joltin' Joe DiMaggio.
Joe, Joe DiMaggio We want you on our side
He tied the mark at forty-four July the 1st you know Since then he's hit a good twelve more Joltin' Joe DiMaggio
Joe, Joe DiMaggio We want you on our side
From coast to coast that's all you'll hear Of Joe the one man show He's glorified the horsehide sphere Joltin' Joe DiMaggio
Joe, Joe DiMaggio We want you on our side
He'll live in baseball's Hall of Fame He got there blow by blow Our kids will tell their kids his name Joltin' Joe DiMaggio
We dream of Joey with the light brown plaque Joe, Joe DiMaggio We want you on our side
And now they speak in whispers low Of how they stopped our Joe One night in Cleveland Oh Oh Oh Goodbye streak DiMaggio
And get this, kids: the name of one of the two writers of the song was -- I am not making this up -- Ben Homer. Gotta love it.
Oops, sorry Bunker Hill! I moved your post over to the new thread so that it addresses what it was attended to address. I was pretty hasty with that split-off. all best, Johnm
Check out Baseball's Greatest Hits and have a listen to "The Ball Game" by Sister Wynona Carr as well as "Did You See Jackie Robinson Hit That Ball?" by Count Basie.
Also, Bob Dylan's "Catfish" (about Catfish Hunter) is acoustic & bluesy, but imho it's neither his best song nor the best song about baseball.
« Last Edit: November 10, 2007, 02:19:16 PM by outfidel »
Of course, we're all proceeding under the assumption that you have to perform an existing song. The other option is to write one of your own. Grab a melody and start setting down some lyrics, like:
When Satchel Paige is on the mound, he will make the batters dance Satchel Paige is on the mound, he will make those batters dance When he gets two strikes on 'em, they won't even stand a chance
He'll walk the bases loaded but he'll take it all in stride He will walk the bases loaded and he'll take it all in stride He'll just rear back with his fastball and he'll strike out the side
And on and on...
Just google Negro League Baseball for players and biographical details.
Thanks everyone. Great suggestions as always. I'll keep you posted if this comes to be. Really dug the old Brownie Roby-Doby number. More of a Wynonie Harris sort of Jump Blues, but some fun lyrics and subject matter.
Memphis Minnie sings of going on the game in Hustlin' Woman Blues 1935
I'm goin' to the quarter bowl, see what I can find I'm goin' to the quarter bowl, see what I can find And if I make a hundred dollors I will bring my daddy ninety-nine
Hey Jon, too late I suppose, but I found a baseball song by Minnie Mathes called Ball Game Blues. It's a slightly jazzy sounding 12-bar blues and can be found on the Document CD Blue Ladies 1934-1941. She's accompanied by Buster Bennett on alto sax, Charlie McCoy on mando, Willie Bee James, gtr. Not a particularly interesting song, but it's about baseball. At least, I think it's about baseball:
Ball Game Blues - Minnie Mathes
Today is a rough day (our off day?), let's play a game of ball Today is a rough day (our off day?), let's play a game of ball Now, pitch to me, daddy, so I can catch them all
I'll be your catcher, I'd like to see you wind and throw I'll be your catcher, I'd like to see you wind and throw [ ][ ] daddy and don't throw the ball too low
Throw in my mitt, daddy, now throw to the one you love Throw in my mitt, daddy, now throw to the one you love Now throw it in the name of the good Lord up above
When it come [ ] daddy, let me wipe your bat for you When it come [ ] daddy, let me wipe your bat for you So when you knock your line driver, you won't break your bat in two
You are my pinch hitter now we got all the bases full You are my pinch hitter now we got all the bases full If you strike out you don't mean me no good
There is a cd of all baseball related songs from Bob Dylan's radio shows on XM, his Theme Time Radio Hour. Tracks like 'Baseball Boogie' by Mabel Scott, 'Home Run' by Chance Halladay, 'Baseball Baby' by Johnny Darling, 'The Ball Game' by Sister Wynona Carr and my favorite, 'Say Hey(the Willie Mays song) by the Treniers With Willie Mays!!!