If you've ever been hurt by your main squeeze, deceived by your best friend, or down to your last dime and ready to call it quits, Albert King has the solution if you have the time to listen. - Deanie Parker, "Born Under A Bad Sign" liner notes, 1967
Will Batts recorded Country Woman in August 1933 for Vocalion, probably with Jack Kelly and Dan Sane on guitars. They were playing out of Spanish tuning, and discussion of the musical accompaniment can be found here.
I have some trouble spots in the lyrics. Line 3 of the first verse is not clear to me. The first option I include is from a transcription on the internet, though I am not sure I buy it. The 2nd option is my guess. Other spots in square brackets as well. Any help appreciated!
Country Woman Blues - Will Batts Spanish tuning
I've got two women in the country, I've got two women stays in town (yeah, boy) I've got two women in the country, I've got two women stays in town Reason I can fiddle it so careful, 'cause nar' don't dog me around
Say, you may be brownskin woman, great God, your hair long as my arm (all right, sing it) Say, you may be brownskin woman, great God, your hair long as my arm (yeah) Can't do the bedspring poker, you sure done lost your home
(Well, play it, boy!)
[Know] the short-haired woman waitin' for to carry your troubles on Make you think through the daytime, trouble you all night long (Why?) She make you think you right, when you know darn well you wrong (yeah, boy)
I don't want no jealous-hearted women, great God, makin' up my bed I don't want no jealous-hearted women, great God, makin' up my bed Man, she put somethin' in your mattress, make you wish you was dead
« Last Edit: July 18, 2020, 10:03:42 PM by Johnm »
Uncle bud, I think the phrase in 1.3 is, "Reason I consider it so careful". The only reason I know that is because Frank Basile pointed it out to me--I wasn't hearing it either. I think Frank Stokes used the line in one of his songs with fiddle. All best, Johnm
UB -- I'm hearing "fiddle" in 1.3 and "nar' none" for the other bit in brackets. I think he means he can get away with having four women because none of them bother him about it. Chris
I'm with Chris on the last line of the first verse:
"Reason I can FIDDLE it so careful 'cause NE'ER NONE dog me around"
Also, I'd transcribe the first line of verse three as:
"KNOW THE short-haired woman waitin' for to carry your troubles on", with the phrase understood to be "You know the short-haired woman...", but the "you" left out in this case.
Sorry for the delay in responding, things have been kind of hectic. I got a chance to go back and listen some more with all the suggestions in mind. For the line in question, I am hearing
Reason I can FIDDLE it so careful 'cause NAR' DON'T dog me 'round
Or should that be NE'ER, as in neither? I am pretty sure I am hearing a D sound in DON'T rather than an N sound for NONE. I really hear the F sound in FIDDLE, and indeed the rest of the word as well.
Johnm mentioned Frank Stokes using this line somewhere and I was able to track it down after much listening to Papa Frank himself. Never a bad thing. The (very similar) line occurs in "Downtown Blues (Take 2)" and was transcribed in the Frank Stokes lyrics thread as "Reason, I can feel it so careful, 'cause nar' one don't thrown me down". I think Stokes is singing "FIDDLE IT" as well in his version. Worth noting he sings "DON'T throw me down".
The meaning Chris proposes sounds reasonable to me, though I guess we won't know for sure without seeing other examples of this expression/sentiment. I wonder though whether "fiddle it" -- if that is correct, as I think it is -- comes as well quite literally from the the fact that Batts was a fiddler, who of course played on a number of Stokes' recordings. It doesn't make sense chronologically, since as far as recording dates go, Stokes and Sane recorded Downtown Blues in February 1928 while Batts, Sane and Jacky Kelly (prob.) recorded Country Woman in August 1933. But there's nothing to say this verse doesn't pre-date both of those recordings and is just a verse that this gang of musicians would use, possibly originating with Batts. Pure speculation!
Edited to add: Forgot to deal with verse 3. I'm considering dj's suggestion that it begins "KNOW, the short-haired woman...". I'm still waffling, but it makes some sense. This verse also appears in a Frank Stokes song: Mistreatin' Blues. In that song, it sounds like it could be "ANOTHER short-haired woman" but Stokes regularly adds the syllable ah/a/uh in front of many words for rhythmic effect, and this could instead be a case of that habit. So the line there would be "AH KNOW THE short-haired woman waitin' to carry your troubles on." Dunno.
Also forgot to address the question of I've/I'm. I hear what you're saying, fellas, though I think it is more I'mve, or I'm've, but for simplicity's sake I am leaving it as I've.
« Last Edit: July 15, 2012, 09:48:08 AM by uncle bud »
Reason I can FIDDLE it so careful 'cause NAR' DON'T dog me 'round
Or should that be NE'ER, as in neither? I am pretty sure I am hearing a D sound in DON'T rather than an N sound for NONE. I really hear the F sound in FIDDLE, and indeed the rest of the word as well.
Johnm mentioned Frank Stokes using this line somewhere and I was able to track it down after much listening to Papa Frank himself. Never a bad thing. The (very similar) line occurs in "Downtown Blues (Take 2)" and was transcribed in the Frank Stokes lyrics thread as "Reason, I can feel it so careful, 'cause nar' one don't thrown me down".
might nary be the intended word - would that have been a common usage? It means (or meant once upon a time) not any, never, as in nary a sound.
I'm having a rough time making this out, any help much appreciated! Here's what I have: President Blues ? Jack Kelly & South Memphis Jug Band (Will Batts, fiddle)
I?m walking round in Memphis, I?m telling ?.. didn?t have a dime
Don?t people go to see Roosevelt, I would have gone up ?..?
He woke up one morning, ?? He begin to thinking about his poor people, and he begin to feel sad
Fiddle
If I had four or five dollars, that would make everything all right If I don?t see no dinner, I?ll see you for a kiss goodnight
I believe I believe, President he?s all right I believe I believe, President he?s all right He kept me from going, out there to have a big fight.
« Last Edit: July 18, 2020, 10:05:04 PM by Johnm »
Love the fiddle part on this! Would appreciate help with lyrics.
I had a little dog his name pour soul ?..But he Run to the door He done done it, he done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy really got your water on
Now the cat told the water (otter?) swimming around Thought he had?. but he ?..went down He done done it, he done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy really got your water on
Now ?.baby crossed the roof Couldn?t do a thing but wiggle and (then?) shoot She done done it, she done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy really got your water on
Now two little boys, lay in the bed One turned over what d?you reckon he said He done done it, (he) done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy really got your water on
I red Good potatoes at the bottom of the till He done done it, done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy got your water on
Now, Two little boys, lay in the bed, One turned over what d'you Reckon HE said He done done it, he done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy got your water on
Now the 4 legged rooster told the 9 headed hen Meet me down here cause you know we ain?t no kin He done done it, done done it, Now you High powered mama , daddy got your water on
John, I agree, the beginnings of most of those verses are near impossible to hear (I had given up on the first verse but now I can totally hear what you heard). It seems like you and Suzy have most of them worked out pretty good. For the potatoes verse though I think it goes: I raised potato, bottoms, raised 'em on the hill Yes, they good potatoes asked her put em in the till
At first that didn't make sense to me as I think of a till involving money but its definition is less specific and can refer to any container, box, etc. Also it makes the chorus 'She done, done it' make a little more sense.
I was also helped by Youtube allowing you to slow down a song, at half speed it was easier to make out the line.
« Last Edit: April 18, 2017, 10:54:22 AM by TenBrook »
You guys are awesome! I wasn't even thinking of working up this song to perform, it's to satisfy the voracious appetite of my local string band blues class for material they haven't heard before. It's so funny how many of those verses, or versions of them, crop up in so many other songs.
Hi all, Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band recorded "Believe I'll Go Back Home" at their first recording session, in New York City on August 1, 1933. For the song, Kelly accompanies himself out of E position in standard tuning, which was fairly unusual for him, since he almost always played in Spanish tuning. A second guitarist, described on the JSP set "Memphis Shakedown" as "probably Dan Sane" plays second guitar, contributing flat-picked bass runs, similarly out of E position in standard tuning, and Will Batts, on fiddle, and D.M. "Doctor" Higgs, on jug, round out the band. The guitarists' approach to duet playing is something of a precursor to the approach taken several years later, on Little Buddy Doyle's records, with both guitars playing busily, pretty much right on top of each other. Kelly really was an exciting singer. Here is the group's performance:
INTRO SOLO
I believe, I believe, I believe I'll go back home I believe, I believe, I believe that I'll go back home I'm gon' acknowledge to my baby, that I have done her wrong
St. Louis is on a fire, Chicago is burning down St. Louis is on a fire, Chicago is burning down I'm sick and tired of my baby foolin' 'round
Babe, please forgive me, I know that I've done you wrong Oh baby, please forgive me, I know that I've done you wrong I'm gon' get down on my knees, I wants my little old baby back home
ENSEMBLE SOLO
It's the same old fireman, same old engineer It's the same old fireman, same old engineer And they took my baby, and left me standing here
Hi all, I merged three earlier threads on songs performed by Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band into this new dedicated thread, so it instantaneously has over a thousand views--pretty cool! All best, Johnm
Will Batts is generally tuned low on these recordings, right? I remember reading that in a thread here, but I'm not sure which one. I was messing around with "Policy Rag" on my fiddle and it sounded like C position tuned down to about A.
Hi all, For "Diamond Buyer Blues", recorded in Memphis on July 14, 1939, Jack Kelly works out of E position in standard tuning, with a seconding flat-picking guitarist (who does not sound like Dan Sane) providing bass support while Will Batts fiddles. Will Batts is recycling a lot of his favorite licks here. "Manicure" seems like a good possibility for a word appearing only once in blues lyrics. Here is the group's performance of "Diamond Buyer Blues":
FIDDLE INTRO
I will buy you a diamond, manicure your fingernails I will buy you a diamond, baby, manicure your fingernails Says, I will stand a trial, baby, lay out some time in the county jail
Somebody, somebody, been trimmin' off my horse's mane Somebody, somebody, been trimmin' off my horse's mane Well, that will be all right, baby, I'll see you just the same
I can tell when my woman's kidman come in town I can tell when my woman's kidman, when he come in town She will go get them soft-sleepin' teddies, and them good old soft-sleepin' gowns
FIDDLE
I had a dream last night, and it really was tight I had a dream last night, and it really was tight It seemed to me like, my baby, she ain't treatin' me right
Hi all, Jack Kelly and the band recorded "World Wandering Blues" at their last session, the July 14, 1939 date in Memphis. I don't know who his seconding guitarist was for the session, but they grooved especially intensely together, and from the sound of it, their intensity jacked Will Batts up, too. They blow the lid off on the solo. Jack Kelly works out of E position in standard tuning here, and the second guitarist flat picks out of G position in standard tuning. There is wonderful singing from Jack Kelly, as per usual, and he always had interesting lyrics, too. Here is the song:
FIDDLE INTRO
I am in this world, wanderin', wanderin' from town to town I am in this world, wanderin' from town to town Well, if I find my baby, I'm gonna run her just like she was a hound
Will, if you play the violin, I will do the howlin' Will, if you play the violin, I will do the howlin' Well, bein' late at night, these women will turn to prowlin'
I am a man, I says, of this kind I am a man, I says, of this kind Well, I get a long ways, just to try to make me a dime
SOLO
It's three o'clock in the mornin', by the clock hangin' up on the wall Well, it's three o'clock in the mornin', by the clock hangin' up on the wall My baby used to come home at midnight, now she don't come home at all
Hi all, Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band recorded "Flower Blues" at their last session, in Memphis on July 14, 1939. Jack plays out of E position in standard tuning, the unidentified second guitarist flat picks out of G position in standard tuning, and Will Batts fiddles. This blues has a notably tough sound. I would love to have been there at this session and heard in person the two guitarists and the way they worked together. it's worth noting, too, that the way these two guitarists worked together has gone completely unexamined and unplayed by present-day players, just as has the duet sound of Little Buddy Doyle's recordings gone unexamined and unplayed. Here is "Flower Blues":
INTRO
I'd rather see the flowers, growing on top of my baby's grave I'd rather see the flowers, growing on top of my baby's grave Than to see some other man smilin', smilin' in my baby's face
Here I am, here I am, settin' right chere with folded arms Here I am, here I am, settin' right chere with folded arms Well, it seem like all good times, for me, in this old world have gone
My Mother's dead and gone to Glory, my Papa's done th'owed me 'way My Mother's dead and gone to Glory, Papa, he's done th'owed me 'way But to have a low-down dirty heart, baby, to mistreat me this-a-way
ENSEMBLE SOLO
And you take me back, baby, I'll tell you just what I'll do And if you take me back, baby, I'll tell you what I'll do I will work hard and I'll slave, baby, I'll bring that money back home to you
Well, if you play the violin, I will do the howlin' Well, if you play the violin, I will do the howlin' Well, bein' late at night, these women will turn to prowlin'
I know Jack Kelly sings "well" a lot... and I do mean a LOT.. but I always heard the first two lines as starting with "Will, if you play..." - basically shouting out to Will Batts
The ensemble sound on these recordings is one of my favorites ever... and that Flower Blues... gawdamighty!
Thanks for the lyrics catch, Frank. It makes so much sense, and the sound is right, too. I will make the fix. I couldn't agree more about the ensemble sound, especially on the solos. I love the way they're all just blasting, and on some of the solos Jack Kelly and the seconding guitarist are playing runs right in the same register--what a mash-up! It's a treat. All best, Johnm
Hi all, Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band recorded "Cold Iron Bed" at their first session, on August 1, 1933 in New York City. For the session, Jack, who accompanied himself out of Spanish tuning, was joined by Will Batts on fiddle, D.M. Higgs on jug and possibly Dan Sane on seconding guitar. Whoever was playing the seconding guitar sounds to have been working out of A position in standard tuning. This version of the band didn't have quite the intensity of ensemble sound as did the 1939 version of the band, but it still sounds pretty great. Here is "Cold Iron Bed":
INTRO SOLO
Baby, take me up and lay me down in your cool iron bed Baby, take me upstairs, lay me down in your cool iron bed If I don't get no better, I want you to come and rub my head
You's a no-good weed, the cows is gon' mow you down (Spoken: Yeah!) Says, you's a no-good weed, the cows is gonna mow you down And if I was a policeman, I would run you clean out of town
SOLO
Ever since, ever since, my poor Mother been dead (Spoken: Yeah!) Ever since, ever since, my poor Mother been dead The rocks have been my pillow, and the cold ground have been my bed
Baby, I will make everything all right Baby, I'll make everything all right If I don't see you tomorrow, I'll see you tomorrow night
Hi all, Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band recorded "Red Ripe Tomatoes" at their first session, on August 1, 1933 in New York City. Jack Kelly sang lead and played lead guitar out of E position in standard tuning, Will Batts fiddled, Dan Sane (possibly) played seconding guitar, flat-picked, out of G position in standard tuning and D. M. Higgs played jug. Will Batts fiddling seemed like it had a bit more variety in these early cuts of the band, though at the same time, it was probably less intense and bluesy. He sounds here more like he did on the cuts he backed Frank Stokes on, like "Shiny Town Blues". Here is "Red Ripe Tomatoes":
FIDDLE SOLO
I've got a 32.20, shoot just like a .45 I've got a 32.20, shoot just like a .45 I can walk on old Green River levee, babe, I won't have to hide
Now, I ain't gon' sell it, too good to give away I ain't gon' sell it, too good to give away I'm gon' save it for me and my baby, I ain't sayin' 'til some rainy day
Now, red ripe tomatoes, don't forget your T-bone steak Now, your red ripe tomato, don't forget your T-bone steak Well, when you get ready, go to fishin', go over on that Horseshoe Lake
SOLO
Well, Mr. Charlie, you had better watch your men Now, Mr. Charlie, you had better watch your men They all going through the bushes, and they are going in
Hi all, For "Cheatin' Woman", recorded on August 1, 1933 in New York City, will Batts sang the vocal, and sat out the tune on violin, so you're instrumentally left with Jack Kelly playing lead guitar out of Spanish tuning, the unknown second guitarist working out of C position in standard tuning and D. M. Higgs playing the jug. One sort of peculiarity of the band is that they quite often gave a number of tunes in their recorded repertoire the very same instrumental intro, and Will Batts did this to an unusual extent. The solos in the middle of their songs are consistently more exciting and fresher sounding than the opening solos. Perhaps they were inclined to play it a little safe on the intros to avoid screwing up the front ends of takes. Here is "Cheatin' Woman":
INTRO SOLO
Did you ever wake up in the morning, with the blues all 'round your bed? Did you ever wake up in the morning, with the blues all 'round your bed? (Spoken: Yeah, boy!) Thought about your good friend, these are the words you said
"I believe to my soul, woman, Great God, something's going on wrong. I believe to my soul, woman, Great God, something's going on wrong. I couldn't rest last night. I been worried all day long."
SOLO (Spoken during solo: Play it, boy!)
You can always tell when your wife ain't treatin' you right You can always tell when your wife ain't treatin' you right (Spoken: Why?) She mistreats you, talkin', with a fresh man ev'y night
When you come in, she have a towel tied on her head When you come in, she have a towel tied on her head "Husband, your stuff ain't done, I been layin' sick in the bed."
Then you send for the doctor, doctor walk through your door Then you send for the doctor, doctor walk through your door "Man, your wife ain't sick--she just don't want you no more."
All best, Johnm
« Last Edit: July 13, 2018, 06:58:29 AM by Johnm »
Hi all, "Cadillac Baby" might more aptly be considered a Will Batts cut than one by Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band, for Will Batts sang lead on it. The instrumentation on the track features two guitars, a lead part played out of E position in standard tuning, probably by Jack Kelly and a second guitar flat-picking out of G position in standard tuning. The JSP set I have the track on identifies Dan Sane as the probable second guitarist, but the touch of the player really does not sound like Dan Sane. Perhaps more likely, it is Will Batts playing the second guitar himself. Whoever it is, the duo has a wonderful sound. In any event, here is "Cadillac Baby":
INTRO SOLO
Ahhh, somebody learned my baby how to shift gear on a Cadillac 8 Ahhh, somebody learned my baby how to shift gear on a Cadillac 8 Every since that day, I can't keep my baby straight
Ahhh, I was warned, baby, I'm gon' let you have your way Ahhh, I was warned, baby, I'm gon' let you have your way 'Cause every dog, he sure got to have his day
SOLO
Ahhh, I said, late one evenin', I looked over your keyhole door Ahhh, I said, late one evenin', I looked through your keyhole door Woman, you know you done me wrong, I ain't comin' back here no more
Ahhh, I turned right around, these are the words I said, Ahhh, I turned right around, these are the words I said, "Nobody don't have to tell me, 'cause I heard the springs cry on your bed."
Hi all, The subject of "High Behind Blues" is exactly what you might think it would be. Jack Kelly, working out of Spanish tuning, is seconded by a guitarist flat-picking out of C position in standard tuning, with (most likely) Will Batts fiddling. Here is "High Behind Blues":
FIDDLE INTRO
I've got a girl, she is made high behind I've got a girl, she is made high behind Every time I feel it, she will give me a dime
She turned right around, and she begin to grin She turned right around, and she begin to grin "I ain't had none of this, Lord, in God knows when."
Well, it's look-a-here, baby, what you gonna do? Well, it's look here, baby, baby, what are you gonna do? Now, you may be lovin', and you jumped up and through
SOLO
If I get hands off of you, baby, it will be too sad If I get hands off of you, baby, it will be too sad You splitting up our lovin', some stuff I really have had
All best, Johnm
« Last Edit: July 12, 2018, 06:45:06 PM by Johnm »
Hi all, Jack Kelly & His South Memphis Jug Band recorded "Joe Louis Special" at a session in Memphis on July 14, 1939. The band that day featured Jack Kelly singing and accompanying himself out of Spanish tuning with an unknown second guitarist working out of C position in standard tuning and probably Will Batts on fiddle. I would say definitely Will Batts on fiddle, since he plays the same intro Will Batts played on almost all of the band's recorded repertoire. Here is "Joe Louis Special":
FIDDLE INTRO
If you give Joe what he want, that will be a big mistake If you give Joe what he wants, that will be a big mistake And he will hit you so hard, 'til you will want to jump in the lake
Now, steak and gravy, that's his favorite dish Well, steak and gravy, that is his favorite dish Well, he'll draw back, make you want to jump in the lake
Now, Joe ain't too lean, and ain't too fat, that wicked left he got, says, John Henry will tell you that Now, Joe ain't too lean, and he ain't too fat Now, that wicked left he's got, John Henry will even tell you that
FIDDLE SOLO
Now, along come John Henry, hit you on the chin, but he won't need no tellin', when he meet Joe Louis again Now, along come John Henry, and he hit Joe right on the chin But, he really won't need no tellin', when he meets Joe Louis again
Hi all, Jack Kelly recorded "Neck Bone Blues" at a session in Memphis on July 14, 1939 for which he was joined by an unnamed seconding guitarist and almost certainly Will Batts on violin. Kelly, as was most often the case on his recordings, accompanies himself out of Spanish tuning capoed up and the seconding guitarist sounds to be flat-picking or using a thumbpick to back him up out of C position in standard tuning. There are a couple of places that I can't hear what is being sung, and I'd very much appreciate help with them, as well as corrections of anything I have wrong thus far. Here is "Neck Bone Blues":
INTRO
Mmm, when you buy neck bone, go to a meat-sellin' house When you buy neck bones, go to a meat-sellin' house They are clean and sanitary, and you really can thaw 'em out
The time has got so hard, caused a many man to eat neck bones The time has got so hard, caused a many man to eat neck bones And it don't get no better, says I will be long gone
Get you a nickel's worth of feet, and a dime's worth of bones Get you a nickel's worth of feet, and get you a dime's worth of bones You talkin' 'bout something good, it will be happiness in your home
ENSEMBLE SOLO
Well, pass around the ginger, babe, and let's do the twist Well, pass around the ginger, babe, and let's do the twist Now the woman's cooked these bone, says I'm really missin'
CODA
Edited 6/6 to pick up corrections from Blues Vintage
All best, Johnm
« Last Edit: June 09, 2022, 12:59:18 PM by Johnm »
They are clean and sanitary, and you really can thaw 'em out
The time hasis got so hard, caused a many man to eat neck bones The time hasis got so hard, caused a many man to eat neck bones
Not sure of 'caused'.
You gon' buy her something good, it will be happiness in your home
Well, pass around the gin jugginger, babe, and let's do the twist Well, pass around the gin jugginger, babe, and let's do the twist Now the woman's cooked these bones, says I really miss
I don't hear "I really miss". But don't know what it could be
I think he sings "bone" in every verse not "bones".
« Last Edit: June 06, 2022, 02:50:47 PM by Blues Vintage »
Thanks for the suggestions, Blues Vintage. I agree with your solution for the tagline of the first verse. I"m still hearing "has" in the second verse, and "bones". I think the tagline in the third verse begins "You talkin' 'bout". I agree that it is "ginger" in the first two lines of the last verse--that's the way I heard it originally and I think you're right. See if you think I got the end of the tagline in the last verse right. I'll make a couple of those changes you suggested. Thanks!
« Last Edit: June 06, 2022, 06:32:40 PM by Johnm »
How the woman[ s ] cooked these bones, that['s] I really miss
I'm uncertain about the [ s ] following "woman." (I added spaces to prevent it from appearing as a strikeout.) I'm also unsure about "s" following "that."
Edited to add: I listened again, this time slowing it down to try to get a better sense of what is being sung between "that" and "I." It is possible what I'm hearing as "s" at full speed is a contraction of "that's what." Perhaps "tha's't" would be one way of representing it using modified spelling to approximate the pronunciation. --"That's what I really miss," using standard English spelling.
« Last Edit: June 08, 2022, 04:06:01 PM by Stuart »
I think this is a very common contraction, Stuart. Most commonly it is used as (spelled out) "That is what I said!" Interestingly, several sounds get voiced in the contraction so a 'ts' sound gets voiced and sounds like a 'z' and the 't' of 'what' gets voiced and sounds like a 'd'. So the contraction usually sounds like ' A'z'd I said', with maybe a schwa ('ə' or 'uh') between the 'z' and 'd'. Try it. Just rolls off the tongue because you've probably said it many times yourself. Here he does pronounce the initial 'th' sound.
Wax
Logged
"People who say it cannot be done should not interrupt those who are doing it." George Bernard Shaw
“Just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they aren't after you.” Joseph Heller, Catch-22
I was simply stating what I hear on the present state of the recording, knowing that there's variation in pronunciation. If my younger self (with much better hearing) was present when the song was recorded, I'm pretty sure I would have heard things differently than I do now on the recording.
I'm not arguing about the sounds of language and how they vary. Even though the present state of the recording is several steps removed from being there during the original performance, I take it as the primary source. Any attempt on my part to help approximate what I hear on the recording is secondary at best--And even that is an overly generous estimate.