I'm worried they won't understand my brogue - Bill Williams, expressing concern to John Miller and Nick Perls with regard to performing for audiences at the 1974 Smithsonian Folklife Festival:
Easily one of my all time favorite McTell songs, if not my favorite. Just for the tremendous energy and virtuoso guitar playing. I believe McTell never sang better. I don’t know why I waited this long to make a transcription.
2.1 I think he misspeaks here with the “she”, but I think the missing word is “placed” – so it comes out as: She placed my head down in a New York woman’s lap but he means I placed my head – Charlie Patton sings pretty much the same verse in one of the Jim Lees – I forget which part
3.1 BELIEVE instead of bleed
5.1 greet is right
7.1 I think shimmy-shan (or shine) is probably right 7.2 Sounds like he says something like “You got to learn HOW I STEP” or “HALF STEP” – probably a dance and I can’t hear it
8.2 dodge every cop I meet is right
The spoken bit after one thin dime is PLAY IT FOR THE LAST
Thanks Chris. That 7.2 is difficult, I gotta listen some more.
The above videos of "East St. Louis Blues" are identical (the same song). One YouTube US friendly and one YouTube Europe friendly (don't know for other continents).
V4/L1: [And] added as per Johnm's perception of the beginning of the line. I do not hear "And" V5/L1: [to] – I didn’t hear this in the song. Perhaps omitted in error V6/L1: “knowed” – Unusual usage; Perhaps a variant for “knew”
Comments:
"Fall" and "Spring" - Uppercase as per Johnm's suggestion in order to help eliminate possible ambiguity
« Last Edit: June 01, 2022, 04:13:10 PM by Stuart »
Thanks for posting Stuart, but us blues nerds here at WC are familiar with the 1933 recording. If you could post the lyrics with it, that would be cool. Just to see how the earlier recording is different from the later one. No offense at all.
I went through the thread and didn't see the 1933 version, so I posted it for comparison purposes and as a convenience, as having it a few posts away from the '49/'50 version can save some time, for Blues nerds and non-Blues nerds alike.
I plan to post the lyrics, which is SOP around here, but please be patient. I'm presently dealing with a level of visual impairment which slows things down. I had surgery on my right eye in late January and then the left eye began to deteriorate. I'm waiting for a call so I can schedule surgery on the LE. Reading and the necessary re-reading has slowed everything way down--and just not here at WC--and the effects are cumulative when you add it all together. And of course, I have to proofread everything I write several times as well.
Hi Stuart, I'm hearing just a couple of places differently in the "East St. Louis Blues" transcription you did.
3.1 AND I pawned my silver 5.2 When the bluebirds ALL WAS ready to sing 9.2 When the bluebirds all WAS ready to sing
Because this is an 8-bar blues, I would format all of the verses in two lines. It makes the first line look long in some verses, but it indicates the form more clearly and is consistent. I would capitalize "Fall" and "Spring" in the verses where McTell refers to the seasons to differentiate them from the various uses of those words uncapitalized. All best, Johnm
Thanks for the corrections and recommendations. Please look over my updated lyrics and annotations when time permits to see if I have incorporated them correctly. I caught a difference to note regarding the standard English spelling and my representation of Willie's singing of "Georgia."
I've also explained your reasons for using an uppercase S and F for spring and fall in the "Comments" section. If this transcription ever makes it into Weeniepedia, this might be helpful for the reader who is used to only seeing the prescriptive conventions.
Thanks for posting the lyrics, Stuart. I like your lay-out of the transcription and I might use it for upcoming songs. Although it could not be necessary for a lot of lyrics. To make adding to Weeniepedia easier, you could change "guitar intro" to "INTRO" and "guitar break" to "SOLO" etc. Because there are no other instruments on the recording. At least that's the way it's been done lately when posting lyrics. We're striving for the most accurate lyrics as we can. But I think we also should try to keep the transcriptions simple and minimal where possible.
I think there's a very quick "and" before 8.1
And I laid my head in a barroom door
« Last Edit: June 02, 2022, 05:28:17 AM by Blues Vintage »
I followed your recommendations and made the changes.
I rarely do transcriptions anymore, so I'm out of practice, to say the least. Plus, my hearing isn't that great so anything I'd do would be more of an exercise in correction for other forum members than a contribution on my part.
As I wrote, the layout or format is merely a starting point and something tangible to work with. We have to be flexible as different songs requires different approaches. And I agree, we don't want to overdo things--but we don't want to underdo things, either. We shouldn't be minimalists simply to strive for minimalism, IMHO. Let circumstances dictate.
Transcribing "East St. Louis Bules" and just turning 72 caused me to reflect on my ~50 years ago younger self when I was listening to Yazoo 1005, "The Early Years," and Atlantic SD 7224, "Atlanta 12 String" (still got 'em) and transcribing lyrics. Half a century has passed and I still can't get it right.
Hi all, Blind Willie McTell recorded "Georgia Rag" at a session in Atlanta on October 31, 1931, accompanying himself out of C position in standard tuning. The song uses a more or less common raggy progression with a few of McTell's own wrinkles and innovations in it, and seems to have been based, at least partially, on Blind Blake's "Wabash Rag". Here is "Georgia Rag":
INTRO
Down in Atlanta on Harris Street, that's where the boys and gals do meet Doin' that rag, that Georgi' Rag
Out in the alley, in the street, every little kid that you meet Doin' that rag, that Wa-Georgia Rag (Spoken: Swing that Georgia Rag, boy)
SOLO
Buzz all 'round like a bee, shake it like a ship on the sea That wild rag, that crazy rag, better known as the Georgia Rag
Came all the way from Paris, France, come into Atlanta to get a chance to Do that rag, that Georgia Rag (Spoken: Pull it little bit for me)
INTERLUDE
That Georgia Rag
Grab me, mama, and hold me tight, let's mess around the rest of the night Doin' that rag, that Georgia Rag (Spoken: Swing that Georgia Rag)
I'm crazy 'bout the Georgia Rag, I'm wild about the Georgia Rag I mean that Georgi' Rag, Georgi' Rag Buzz all 'round like a bee, shake it like a ship on the sea That wild rag, that crazy rag, better known as the Georgia Rag (Spoken: Now whup it)
INTERLUDE (Spoken: That somethin' make you feel good, right in there)
Wa-throw your hands way up high, grab your daddy and make him cry Doin' that rag, that Georgia Rag
Wild about the Georgia Rag, you're wild about the Georgia Rag I mean that Georgi' Rag, Georgi' Rag 'Cause you buzz all 'round like a bee, shake it like a ship on the sea That wild rag, that crazy rag, better known as the Georgia Rag (Spoken: Aw, whup it now)
INTERLUDE
Oh you shake it like a ship on the sea, buzz around like a bee Oh that Georgi' Rag, that wild rag, better known as the Georgia Rag
People come from miles around, get in Darktown to break 'em down Doin' that rag, that Georgi' Rag
Out in Darktown night and day, tryin' to dance them blues away Doin' that rag, that Georgia Rag (Spoken: All right now, boy, spank 'em)
SOLO
That wild rag, that crazy rag, better know as the Georgia Rag
Goin' all the way back to Newport News, singin' these doggone Atlanta blues 'Bout that rag, that Georgi' Rag (Spoken: All right now, play that Georgia Rag)
INTERLUDE
'Cause you buzz all 'round like a bee, shake it like a ship on the sea That wild rag, that crazy rag, better known as the Georgi' Rag
CODA
Edited 7/20 to pick up corrections from Blues Vintage
All best, Johnm
« Last Edit: July 20, 2022, 06:02:18 AM by Johnm »
2nd verse; Could McTell mean Wa-Georgia rag? As Blake sings Wabash Street/Wabash Rag. Don't know if there is or was a Wabash street in Georgia. Or he just still heard echos of Wabash in his mind.
Thanks very much for the suggestions, Blues Vintage, I've incorporated all of them. The suggestion that McTell started to sing "Wabash" in those two places and then caught himself is brilliant, I think. I think this one is ready to go, thanks!