Topic: Snooks Eaglin--"Lipstick Traces"

[Johnm]

Hi all,
Pan found this wonderful video of Snooks Eaglin and posted it over on facebook (thank, Pan!).  I thought to add it here.  It's not Country Blues of course, but it is so great, and it's actually not all that far removed from the harmonic language of things like Virgil Childers' version of "Travellin' Man" or "Preacher And The Bear".  Here's the video:

Snooks Eaglin with George Porter Jr.- Lipstick Traces [3/6]

For any of you who might be interested in figuring it out and playing it, here's the progression for "Lipstick Traces"

   ||:    F    |    F    |    Em7   |    A7    |

   |    Dm   |   Dm   |   Cm7   |    F9    |

   |    Bb     |  Bdim7  |  F    A7  |    D7   |
                                                1
   |    G7     |C7 (stop) |  F   Bb  |  C aug  :||
                                                2
                                               |    F       |
BRIDGE
   |     C7    |   C7 Caug |     F      |   F  A7   |

   | Dm   Dm7  |   G7    |    C7   |  C7  Caug  |
OUT A
   |    F    |   F      |    Em7    |    A7    |

   |    Dm    |    Dm    |    Cm7    |    F9    |

   |    Bb      |  B dim7   |  F     A7   |    D7   |

   |    G7     |   C7 (break)  |   F   Bb   |  F   (C7)  |

In the ending vamp, they're playing
   ||:  F   A7   |     Dm    :||

Snooks was such an ace, and his mastery of F was wonderful to behold.

All best,
Johnm     
 

[Bunker Hill]

With eyes closed one could almost almost be forgiven for thinking it was Benny Spellman himself singing this. Over time there have been may attempts at this Allen Toussaint penned classic but this nails it. The bassist looks to me like George Porter.

[Rivers]

Yes indeed. He's so free in what he does and it always comes out really tasteful..

I see the song is included on his Out Of Nowhere CD, same arrangement: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B000005YWM/ref=dm_dp_cdp?ie=UTF8&s=music. The rest of the CD, from listening to the samples, seems to be straight ahead R&B and jazzy blues, which is OK by me.

[Rockdale]

This is such a cool song and I love George Porter Jr.'s vocals on this one. It looks like they were having a lot of fun playing it, too.

[Johnm]

Hi all,
I realized this morning that "Lipstick Traces" bears more than a passing resemblance to a song that has already been discussed here in the "Rag Blues and Circle of Fifths" thread at:  http://weeniecampbell.com/yabbse/index.php?topic=712.msg8074#msg8074 , Leroy Carr's "Longing For My Sugar".  "Longing For My Sugar" is a 12-bar blues, unlike "Lipstick Traces", which is a 32-bar Pop song form, but look at the progression of "Longing For My Sugar", and you'll see that the progression for the A parts of "Lipstick Traces" employs essentially the same progression, but writ large, and in a bit more harmonic detail.  Here's "Longing For My Sugar", transposed to F, the key Snooks performed "Lipstick Traces" in.

   |   F    |   A7   |    Dm    |    F7    |

   |  Bb   | Bdim7 |    F      |    D7    |

   |  G7   |   C7    | turn-|  around   |

In both songs, the initial harmonic movement is from I major to it's relative minor, VI minor, from which you move into IV and then a I-VI-II-V-I circle of fifths, with the VI, II and V chords all dominant sevenths.  "Lipstick Traces" doubles up all the lengths in which chords are held at the front end of the progression, and unlike "Longing For My Sugar", which always gets to the next key area via the V7 of that key area, e.g., A7 for D minor and F7 for Bflat, "Lipstick Traces" effects the movement to different key areas with a IIm7--V7 progression, e.g., Em7-A7 for D minor and Cm7-F7 for Bflat.  If you look at "Lipstick Traces" progression, in the A parts, at the roots of the odd numbered measures, you get a descending major scale, as per:
  F--Em7--Dminor--Cminor7--Bflat--A7--G7--F.
As Mel Allen used to say, "How about that!"
This same progression was utilized, with minor tweaks, by Charlie Parker for his tune, "Confirmation", and, at least, through the IV chord, by Harry Warren for his great standard, "There Will Never Be Another You".  It's a wonderful progression, really a great ride, and fun to improvise over, and it has the additional benefit of being able to accommodate completely different sorts of melodies.  If you've any doubt of the different melodic possibilities implicit in this progression, go to YouTube and search for renditions of "Confirmation" and "There Will Never Be Another You", bearing in mind that they have very close to the same progression as "Lipstick Traces".  And it's especially cool when you reflect that the progression comes right out of the blues tradition.
All best,
Johnm     

[Pan]

Thanks John, that's really interesting.

I've usually associated these types of changes to  bebop, even in the 12-blues format. Like with Parker's "Blues For Alice", and such. It's nice to know that our blues heroes came up with these kind of changes even earlier on!

 Here's a chart for "Blues For Alice" (I couldn't find an original YouTube video with Parker).



Here's a video of the Leroy Carr And Scrapper Blackwell tune, "Longing For My Sugar" (frustratingly cutting short of the song):

Leroy Carr And Scrapper Blackwell - Longing For My Sugar

Cheers

Pan